Writers respond to presentation about fracking
To the editor,
In response to the article published on May 10 we would like to offer information which contradicts Mr. Osman’s statements.
Mr. Osman began his presentation with “hydraulic fracturing is a highly regulated industry.”
The natural gas industry has been without federal regulation since 2005 when President Bush signed what is called the “Halliburton Loophole” which currently exempts the industry from seven major federal regulations: Safe Water Drinking Act, Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, The Superfund Law, the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the Toxic Release Inventory under the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act.
The process of fracking has been around since 1940, he is right about this, but the process of horizontal fracking is a recent advancement in hydrocarbon drilling.
Mr. Osman said all the water was reclaimed, treated and cleaned.
The waste water produced in the fracking process is called produced water, and contains many toxic chemicals. Often this water sits in unlined holding ponds with the effects to the surrounding land and water as yet unknown.
Recycling this produced water, or “slick water,” is in its infancy. Very few companies are doing this because the expense is enormous.
Recycling would also require the expense of transport to specially designed, extremely expensive facilities that can separate fluid from waste. In some instances, disposing of the waste water by injecting it into the ground has been linked to earth quake activity.
Mr. Osman stated there has not been one single documented case of water contamination. Correct; there have been hundreds.
Entire neighborhoods have water buffalos (water tanks) in the yard because their drinking water is unfit for drinking or bathing.
Documentation is rare, as gas companies have paid off residents with money and instituted gag orders to keep them from reporting their problems to authorities. Even when reported to authorities, nothing is done.
Let’s be real clear with the semantics here. When opponents of fracking refer to contamination or pollution, in particular instance of water, by the process of fracking, we mean the entire process: vertical, horizontal, wet or dry, from excavating to drilling, from fracking to extraction, to waste disposal into wells and ponds.
An economic boom? That indeed would be a wonderful opportunity. Except that natural gas is a finite resource and the current industry estimations are exactly that; estimations and inflated projections.
Matter of fact, in August of 2011, USGS studies of Marcellus Shale Gas cut estimates by nearly 80 percent, from 410 trillions to 84 trillion. Currently large amounts of natural gas sit waiting to be exported to other countries. We don’t have enough storage capacity as it is.
It is our belief much more could be accomplished by investing in studying sustainable energy sources rather than extracting fossil fuels with limited remaining supplies.
Regardless of opinions about climate issues, common sense dictates considering the consequences. What legacy are we leaving future generations of human kind?
While it is true legislation has recently been passed which would require chemical disclosure, such disclosure would only be made to lessees and not to neighboring land owners, giving them no rights to compensation.
Also, if the chemical components are considered a “Trade Secret,” they will not be disclosed.
We need factual information before making such important decisions about our drinking water and the air we breathe.More information is available at dontfractureillinois.org.
Signed, Tabitha Tripp, Anna; Corina Lang, Cobden; Dennis Connelly, Cobden
