Wanting best for our kids
To the editor,
Like a lot of you, I want the best for our kids and school system, however, I do not believe this current referendum is the vehicle to bring about this goal.
The proposition is to form an Optional Elementary Unit School District. This is not like the unit districts of Cobden, Dongola or Shawnee.
You remember in the early 1990s when we voted on consolidating Dongola into the A-J district and it failed because Dongola voted no.
That is because under that statute for a unit district any district voting no defeated the referendum.
The state than developed another statute called the Optional Elementary Unit School District.
Under this statute, when more than one elementary districts were voting, no one district could defeat the referendum if one or more of the districts wanted to consolidate.
The districts wanting to consolidate could consolidate and the ones voting no could keep their own districts. According to the ballot, this is the way we will vote.
Since we have four districts voting it takes only one elementary district and the high school district voting yes for a new district to form while the other districts voting no to keep their separate districts.
There are seven different ways this vote could turn out. I want to address only one of those and its repercussions.
Let’s say that Anna 37 and A-J High School district vote yes and Jonesboro 43 and Lick Creek 16 vote no then a new elementary district with a high school will be formed.
Now Jonesboro and Lick Creek are without a highschool. Where will their students go? In order to go to a school out of your district you have to pay tuition.
Let’s say the new district says we won’t charge tuition. The state pays state aid only for students in that district.
So will the new district lose state aid for all the students not in that district? No one knows at this time.
Now comes the part on the ballot that talks about tax levy. The statute requires that those state figures be put on the ballot for the four funds: educational, operational and maintenance, transportation and special education.
The combined total allowable for K-8 and 9-12 districts is 4.57 and for K-12 districts is 5.75.
Currently using the 2009 tax levy and rounding to the nearest hundredth, the combined Jonesboro 43 and AJHS districts is 2.55, the Anna 37 and AJHS is 2.80, and the Lick Creek 16 and AJHS is 2.33.
The statute for the optional elementary unit school district states that the tax levy for the combined districts can not be more than the previous combined levy prior to the newly formed district.
But what about the years after the new district was formed no one knows. Also do you take the highest or lowest combined tax levy to establish the new district tax levy?
If you take the lowest then taxes will go down and less money will be available.
If you take the highest tax levy then taxes will go up for Jonesboro and Lick Creek residents because it will be a new district and there is no way to separate the old districts. Does anyone believe the lower rate will be used?
School boards can not raise taxes more than .05 without a public hearing. Taking the highest combined rate now of 2.80 and the authorized rate on the ballot for K-12 of 5.75 that is a difference of 2.95. It would take 59 years of increasing the tax levy by .05 to reach 2.95.
At present some of the costs of combining these four districts are heavily dependent on state funding.
Since the state is currently not meeting the required funding Now what makes us believe it will be there when and if we vote to consolidate.
If the state does not provide funding and/or also decreases current funding or continues to under fund than we the tax payers will be required to make up the difference.
In other words, the statutes are only as good as the paper they are written on if the governing body that writes them does not abide by them.
In closing, I, as well as you want the best for our children but to vote on that premise alone is not sound decision making.
Without solid facts on how a new district will be funded, run, and most of all what will happen if one or two of the elementary school districts vote no could do far more damage to the educational system than our present system.
This would not be the best for our children. We need to slow down and do this right and not vote on the idea: hope things work out. There are too many unanswered questions for me to vote yes. I, for one, will vote no on this proposition.
Respectfully yours, Charles W. Neal Jr., Anna
