Fact and fiction

To the editor,

Mr. Bigler and the Committee of Ten seem to have a problem distinguishing between fact and fiction. Let us do that now. . .

Fact 1. Mr. Bigler and the Committee of Ten cannot honestly tell you, the voter, where your children will attend school.

They have neither the authority, nor the power to tell you anything regarding where you child attends school, or the amount of taxes you will pay, for that matter.

In fact, most of what the Committee of Ten tells you, the voter, is purely speculation to support their biased "paid for" agenda.

The Committee of Ten recommends the current four boards be dissolved, and a new board formed. This will reduce the decision making power from 28 persons to seven persons.

From here, it stands to reason then, four individuals (or in the opinion of some, two people) may have the power to decide where your child goes to school.

Fact 2. Indeed, it may not even be up to four people, but rather, the decision regarding where your child  goes to school may lie with the teachers' union.

Class size and salary scales across a newly formed school district will be equalized. No union will allow a seventh grade teacher at Lick Creek to teach eight students, while a seventh grade teacher in Anna has over 20 students, and each make the same amount of money.

Therefore, in order to equalize class size, a seventh grader living in Mill Creek could be bussed to Lick Creek School.

Furthermore, it could be that the entire Lick Creek seventh grade could be bussed to other schools.

This scenario eliminates Lick Creek School's participation in Beta Club activities, Scholar Bowl and other extracurricular activities, namely sports. This scenario could also result in some families having children attending different elementary schools.

Fact 3. When you receive your ballot to vote, you will see that this a vote on a tax levy.

A yes vote will give the new board the power to nearly double your taxes. You will not see an explanation of how the tax money will be spent. If consolidation passes, this is something the new board will decide.

Mr. Bigler wants you to believe that the new board may not raise taxes to the maximum amount. Are you willing to vote that, given the power to double taxes, the new board won't?

Fact 4. Mr. Bigler in a previous letter to the paper insinuated that Lick Creek's financial status was questionable.

In fact, Lick Creek has one, if not the, strongest financial statements of all the districts involved in the consolidation process.

Other districts in southern Illinois, and the state as a whole, would be wise to use Lick Creek School as a model to demonstrate how a school can provide a quality education on the amount of money coming from the state.

In fact, Lick Creek School has the highest financial rating the state gives to any school.

Fact 5. Lick Creek School's enrollment is not decreasing.

Last week, Mr. Bigler's letter stated that from 2002 to 2010 enrollment at Lick Creek went from 134 to 117.

If one looks at the enrollment from 2010 to 2012, enrollment at the school actually increased to 135.

While enrollment fluctuates, unless Mr. Phillips has a crystal ball, he cannot "predict" that Lick Creek's enrollment will drop by 35 students, as this has never happened before.

Additionally, if one looks at the enrollment of the other districts a similiar pattern of fluctuation is demonstrated.

Further, it is ironic Mr. Bigler argued that Lick Creek would be unaffected, and he should be allowed to petition out of the district. This petition costs Lick Creek thousands of dollars per year.

In closing, all 21 community-elected members of the elementary school boards; some, maybe most, of the members of the high school board; all of the elementary school superintendnts; teachers; coaches; highly respected former school superintendents; and locally elected regional superintendent, Janet Ulrich are opposed to school consolidation.

Those in favor of consolidation include a millionaire, with a primary residence in the state of Florida, some of his employed attorneys, and the state superintendent in Chicago, who thinks Buncombe, is a part of the Anna-Jonesboro school district.

This is a bad idea, and it will cost the taxpayers money. Please vote No on March 20, 2012.

Submitted by John Basler, Anna


        Archive Section: 

        The Gazette-Democrat

        112 Lafayette St.
        Anna, Illinois 62906
        Office Number: (618) 833-2158
        Email: news@annanews.com

        Sign Up For Breaking News

        Stay informed on our latest news!